Welcome to Ella New York Pizza and Pasta, a hidden gem nestled on 137 S Main St, New City, NY 10956. This charming eatery combines the warmth of traditional Italian cooking with the vibrant flair of New York-style pizza, making it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts and families alike. With their delicious offerings and a commitment to quality, it's no wonder patrons are raving about their experiences.

At the heart of Ella's menu are a selection of mouthwatering dishes. Their lunch paninis deserve special mention. The Chicken Horseradish Panini takes a bold approach with chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and a zingy horseradish sauce, all for just $14.99. Or try the Caprese Panini, which perfectly balances roasted peppers, arugula, and balsamic vinaigrette, leaving your taste buds dancing.

Starters like the Zucchini Chips and Mozzarella Fresca showcase fresh ingredients and an artistic touch. The crispy zucchini, thinly sliced and lightly fried, offers a delightful crunch while the Mozzarella Fresca, drizzled with balsamic glaze, elevates the classic caprese to pure bliss. Customers have praised the Buffalo Wings and Burrata too, proving that every detail is carefully considered at Ella's.

• Hot Hero Sandwiches: Choices like the Chicken Cutlet and Meatball Parmesan are a hit, each bursting with robust flavors and handmade quality.
• Pasta Dishes: For those in search of hearty Italian fare, don’t miss their rich, flavorful pasta options that are prepared with passion.

Customer reviews speak volumes. Dan Leaird joyously highlights their ability to accommodate gluten sensitivities with a perfectly toasted cauliflower crust. Matthew Ciuccio reminisces about his divine Mons Lasagne, and Lenia C found herself dreaming of their consistently praised pizzas. These testimonials resonate with the comforting and homey atmosphere that Ella New York Pizza and Pasta offers, making it the ideal spot for family gatherings or a casual meal with friends.

As you immerse yourself in the ambiance, you cannot help but feel the welcoming spirit that defines Ella's ethos. With an inviting vibe and gracious staff, including warm service from Giselle, patrons find themselves returning not just for the food, but for the community experience it fosters. Whether you're craving classic New York-style pizza or gourmet pasta, Ella New York Pizza and Pasta is ready to satisfy your culinary desires. Join us, and taste the local love that goes into each dish!

For inquiries or to place your order, you can reach them at +1 845-638-6184 — it's time to savor a slice of New York!